An Economic Analysis of Protect Certificates - An Option-Pricing Approach

An Economic Analysis of Protect Certificates - An Option-Pricing Approach

Rodrigo Hernandez, Jeffrey Jones, Jenny Gu

Abstract

We introduce and describe a new financial product referred to as Protect Certificates and show that the payoff of a Protect Certificate can be duplicated by the combination of a zero coupon bond, call options on the underlying asset and put options on the underlying asset. We develop pricing models for several variations of Protect Certificates and show that issuers receive considerable profit at primary market issuance. We compare the issuers’ profit from Protect Certificates to two other types of structured products, Outperformance Certificates and Bonus Certificates, and find that issuers earn statistically and economically higher profits from the issuance of Protect Certificates. We conclude that buyers highly value the capital protection offered by Protect Certificates, but tend to overpay for this protection.

References

Abken, P. (1989). A survey and analysis of index-linked certificates of deposit, Working Paper –Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, 89 -1.

Baubonis, C., G. Gastineau & D. Purcell (1993). The banker’s guide to equity-linked certificates of deposit. Journal of Derivatives, 1 (Winter), 87-95.

Benet, B., A. Giannetti & S. Pissaris (2006). Gains from structured product markets: The case of reverse-exchangeable securities (RES). Journal of Banking and Finance, 30, 111-132.

Black, F., & M. Scholes (1973). The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities. The Journal of Political Economy, 81, 637-654.

Burth, S., T. Kraus & H. Wohlwend (2001). The pricing of structured products in the Swiss market. Journal of Derivatives, 9, 30-40.

Chance, D., & J. Broughton (1988). Market index depository liabilities. Journal of Financial Services Research, 1, 335-352.

Chen, A., & J. Kensinger (1990). An analysis of market-index certificates of deposit. Journal of Financial Services Research, 4, 93-110.

Chen, K., & R. Sears (1990). Pricing the SPIN. Financial Management, 19, 36-47.

Grünbichler, A., & H. Wohlwend (2005). The valuation of structured products: Empirical findings for the Swiss market. Financial Markets and Portfolio Management, 19, 361-380.

Hernandez, R., J. Brusa & P. Liu (2008). An economic analysis of bonus certificates - Second-generation of structured products. Review of Futures Markets, 16, 419-451.

Hernandez, R., J. Brusa & P. Liu (2010). An economic analysis of bank-issued market-indexed certificate of deposit – An option pricing approach. International Journal of Financial Markets and Derivatives (Forthcoming).

Hernandez, R., W. Lee, P. Liu & T. Dai (2011). Outperformance Certificates: Analysis, Pricing, Interpretation, and Performance. Working Paper.

Hernandez, R., W. Lee & P. Liu (2010). An economic analysis of reverse exchangeable securities - An option-pricing approach. Review of Futures Markets, 19, 67-95.

Hernandez, R., C. Tobler & J. Brusa (2010). Contingent Claim Valuation of Express Certificates. Banking and Finance Review, 2, 2, 119-126

Hernandez, R., C. Tobler & P. Liu (2010). Contingent Claim Valuation-The Case of Certificates Plus Reloaded. Working Paper.

Hull, J. (2003). Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Fifth Edition). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Inc.

King, S. & E. Remolona (1987). The Pricing and Hedging of Market Index Deposits. FRBNY Quarterly Review, 12, 2, 9 - 20.

Isakov, D. (2007, August 28). Le prix élevé de certains instruments tient aux frictions qui apparaissent sur le marché. Le Temps.

Laise, E. (2006, June 21). An Arcane Investment Hits Main Street. Wall Street Journal - Eastern Edition 247(144), D1-D3.

Lyon, P. (2005, October). Editor’s Letter: The NASD guidance does seem to suggest that structured products should be the preserve of the privileged few who are eligible for options trading. Structured Products.

______ (2005, October). US retail in the firing line. Structured Products.

Maxey, D. (2006, December 20). Market builds for structured products. Wall Street Journal - Eastern Edition.

National Association of Securities Dealer, 2005, Notice to Members 05-59 Guidance Concerning the Sale of Structured Products.

Ricks, T. (1988, January 7). SEC Chief Calls Some Financial Products Too Dangerous’ for Individual Investors. Wall Street Journal, p. 46.

Roll, R. (1977) An analytic valuation formula for unprotected american call options on stocks with known dividends. Journal of Financial Economics 5, 251–258.

Stoimenov, P., & S. Wilkens (2005). Are structured products ‘fairly’ priced? An analysis of the German market for equity-linked instruments. Journal of Banking and Finance, 29, 2971-2993.

Simmons, J. (2006, January). Derivatives Dynamo. Bloomberg Markets, 55-60.

Wilkens, S., C. Erner & K. Roder (2003). The pricing of structured products in Germany. Journal of Derivatives, 11, 55-69.

Full Text: Full Text PDF File

The Banking and Finance Review